Education by Curriculum or Education for Development?

Етикети: образование, холистични нужди

Over the past decades, almost every country in the world has spoken about educational reform. Curricula are revised, assessment systems redesigned, technologies introduced, competencies redefined, and new visions for the future constantly emerge. Every new government promises a new educational strategy or a new model for schools. Yet the same questions remain:

  • Why are children losing their motivation to learn?
  • Why are anxiety, stress and aggression increasing?
  • Why are so many teachers leaving the profession?
  • Why, despite enormous investments, do societies continue searching for “the next educational reform”?

Perhaps because educational reform so often begins with curricula, examinations or technology rather than with a far more fundamental question: What is human development?

If we do not understand how human beings develop, it becomes difficult to create an education that truly supports that development.

Traditionally, education has been understood as the transmission of knowledge, skills, values and habits, with the educator as the primary source of knowledge and the child as its recipient. Looking at the origins of the word education, however, we find that it derives from the Latin educare, meaning to bring up, raise or nurture development. Education is therefore fundamentally connected to the growth and development of the human being. For Dr Maria Montessori, education is a process that serves the construction of the human being.

Education is an aid to life. When we speak about education, we often begin by asking: What should children know? What skills will they need twenty years from now? Which professions will exist in the future? These are important questions, but they are secondary. For example, Dr Montessori reverses the order – from the point of view of development, before asking what we should teach, we must first understand whom we are educating. Because the child is not an empty vessel waiting to be filled with knowledge. The child is a developing human being. If education is not grounded in the scientific understanding of human development, it risks following adult assumptions about what children ought to become rather than the developmental realities of who they already are.

Аs human beings, we think, imagine, work and create, using our hands to transform ideas into reality. We acknowledge that mind and hand, thought and action, are deeply interconnected in human development. Unlike other species, the human being does not arrive already constructed. The human newborn possesses extraordinary possibilities that gradually develop through interactions with the environment. Children acquire coordinated movement, language, social behaviour and the culture of the particular human community into which they are born. Through this process, they gradually construct their individual personality, adapted to the world.

This gives adaptation a central place in understanding development. Children actively engage with the physical, social, linguistic and cultural environment and use these experiences to construct themselves. What initially exists outside the child progressively becomes part of the developing personality as the child incarnates reality. For this reason, Dr Montessori placed self-construction at the centre of her educational philosophy. The adult can prepare the environment, guide, protect and offer experiences, but cannot perform the child’s developmental work. That work belongs to the child – to move, explore, repeat, overcome difficulties, correct mistakes, think and discover through purposeful activity.

Dr Montessori outlines:

“The greatness of the human personality begins at the hour of birth. Therefore education must start from birth.”

Maria Montessori, The Absorbent Mind, p. 4.

Here lies one of the greatest challenges facing contemporary education. History shows that education has often reflected the needs and expectations of society more than the developmental needs of children. At different moments in history, schools have been expected to produce obedient citizens, efficient workers or successful university applicants. Today, we increasingly speak about digital literacy, entrepreneurship, artificial intelligence and twenty-first-century competencies. These are all important goals when they are built upon a sound understanding of human development, because technology changes rapidly, labour markets evolve, political priorities shift also. However, the laws of human development, however, do not change. Children still construct themselves through movement and sensory experience, through relationships and language, through meaningful work and through opportunities to discover the world through their own activity. For this reason, true educational reform does not begin with a new curriculum or another textbook. It begins with a deeper understanding of the human being.

If education begins at birth, it begins long before formal schooling. Even the earliest experiences of movement, language, sensory exploration, relationships and communication contribute to the construction of the human being. Through observation, Maria Montessori recognised these constructive forces within development that orient the child towards adaptation and increasing independence. In the first Casa dei Bambini in San Lorenzo in 1907, she observed capacities for concentration, repetition, purposeful activity, order, independence and spontaneous learning that could remain hidden when conditions did not support their expression.

This discovery transforms the role of the adult. If the constructive power belongs to the child, the adult must distinguish between what belongs to development and what belongs to education. Adults can prepare the environment, introduce language and knowledge, model relationships and remove obstacles to development, but they cannot construct the child’s personality from the outside. The power belongs to the developing individual; the adult’s responsibility is to understand and protect the conditions under which that power can operate. Education is therefore most constructive when the external conditions correspond to the developmental needs.

This understanding lies at the foundation of Montessori’s concept of natural development and makes her vision of education holistic. For example, movement supports intelligence; language opens possibilities for thought, abstraction and social interaction; purposeful work integrates the personality through concentration and builds independence; relationships support adaptation; and freedom develops alongside responsibility. The aim is not simply a knowledgeable and capable child, but the development of the whole human being towards physical, intellectual, social and moral independence. As the individual develops through interaction with the environment, physical capacities, ways of thinking, social orientations and relationships with the world are transformed. Development itself changes as the human being progresses towards maturity. This led Dr Montessori to one of her most fundamental educational discoveries: if development changes, education must change with it. As she wrote:

“The path of education should follow the path of evolution, to walk and to enjoy ever wider horizons.”

Maria Montessori, The Absorbent Mind, p. 163.

These “ever wider horizons” change throughout development. The infant moves from profound dependence towards movement and language; the young child towards functional independence; the elementary child towards intellectual and moral exploration; the adolescent towards identity, social participation and economic independence; and the young adult towards mature responsibility and contribution. Dr Montessori describes these profound developmental transitions:

“It seems as if, at a certain period of life, one psychic individual ceases and another is born.”

Maria Montessori, Education for a New World, p. 15.

Това прозрение е в основата на Четирите плана на развитието. Човешкото развитие протича през ясно различими периоди, всеки със своите специфични нужди, чувствителности и задачи пред развитието. Средата, подходяща за един период, не може просто да бъде разширена или усложнена за следващия; всеки план изисква различна форма на помощ за живота. 

Това разбиране става особено актуално днес. Изследванията в областта на невронауката, психологията на развитието и образованието все по-категорично показват, че ученето не е само интелектуален процес – движението подпомага развитието на изпълнителните функции, емоционалната сигурност подпомага паметта и вниманието, социалните взаимоотношения подпомагат езиковото развитие, а любопитството активира системите за учене в мозъка. Или накратко, науката постепенно достига до същото заключение, което Мария Монтесори формулира преди повече от сто години: човекът не може да бъде разделен на отделни учебни предмети.

Може би именно тук се крие големият въпрос пред образованието на XXI век – не дали ще използваме повече технологии, или ще променим изпитите, или ще въведем още един предмет. А дали ще имаме смелостта да изградим образование, което започва от научното разбиране за развитието на човека. Центрираният около детето подход предлага различна от традиционната отправна точка – да започнем не от учебната програма, учебника или тестовете и дори не от въпроса: „Какво трябва да знае това дете?“, а от много по-дълбоки въпроси като:

Кой е този човек в настоящия момент от своето развитие? От каква помощ се нуждае животът в този етап?

Когато тези въпроси станат основа на образованието, тогава реформите престават да бъдат поредната административна промяна. Те се превръщат в нещо много по-значимо –  образование, което следва законите на човешкото развитие и наистина служи на живота.

Author: Anna-Maria Yotsova, Humanitarian & Possibilitarian | AMI International Montessori Teacher (3–6, 6–12, 12–18) | IB Educator | Founder of Discover International School | Co-founder of Montessori Society Bulgaria 

Previous Post
Letter to Our Community
Next Post
Freedom is one of the most important and misunderstood concepts of Montessori pedagogy

Latest News

Letter to Our Community

Discover the Freedom of Learning: Montessori Self-Paced Online Course for Preschoolers (Ages 3-6)

Happy Children’s Day

Montessori Sport: Nurturing Growth Through Movement

Timeline of Maria Montessori’s Life

keyboard_arrow_up